Libertas: Beethoven, Schubert, Seashore, Marx; Äneas Humm, Doriana Tchakarova; Rondeau Manufacturing
Reviewed 19 April 2025
The younger Swiss baritone explores concepts of non-public freedom in an intriguing recital that strikes from Beethoven and Schubert to Amy Seashore (in German) and Joseph Marx
On their new disc, Libertas on the Rondeau Manufacturing label, baritone Äneas Humm and pianist Doriana Tchakarova use the concept of the seek for interior freedom to go on a musical journey encountering composers who, in several methods, strove to achieve particular person independence. The result’s a considerably eclectic but satisfying journey starting with Beethoven, then transferring to Schubert, then 4 of Amy Seashore’s German language songs and eventually a range from Joseph Marx.
We start, in fact with Beethoven, and while Mephistopheles’ ‘Tune of the Flea’ from Goethe’s Faust resonates from all types of different musical contexts, we should do not forget that the track is met within the play with the phrases ‘Lengthy stay freedom’. Right here Humm’s finely characterful, centered baritone is complemented by Tchakarova’s delightfully perky nearly sarcastic piano.
The following three songs see Beethoven exploring extra inward wanting feelings. Sehnsucht dates from across the identical time as An die Ferne geliebte, right here Humm and Tchakarova make Beethoven’s enticing, strophic setting into one thing slightly touching with Tchakarova giving a suggestion of variation type to the piano half. Der Liebende is earlier, relationship from 1809 and right here we now have one thing participating but trendy but remarkably perky. Lastly on this group with have An die Hoffnung from 1805 with its slightly touching melody that provides Humm loads of alternative to caress the vocal line and seduce us together with his tone.
All 4 of those are firmly within the track vein and comprise nothing as daring as Schubert might need tried or which Beethoven did in his different music. That is music firmly aimed on the proficient novice performer, but throughout the confines we will hear the composer exercising his interior creativeness in some ways, significantly in such finely participating and considerate performances as these.
Their Schubert group begins together with his Mayrhofer setting, Der entsühnte Orest with its intriguing image of Orestes gaining freedom in loss of life. Right here Humm’s agency tone and Tchakarova’s expansive piano deliver out the sober, mythic high quality of Schubert’s writing. An mein Herz begins with Tchakarova’s pressing piano but Humm suggests impulsiveness held beneath management, solely opening up in direction of the top. Sehnsucht, setting a unique poem to Beethoven, this time by Schiller and the track is certainly one of Schubert’s grander items, and right here given in an engagingly trendy efficiency filled with nice element. With Gruppe aus dem Tartarus we return to the grandly mythic Schubert in a setting that for all its compactness is sort of operatic in its daring. Right here, you’re feeling that Humm tries to push his voice just a little too far on the climaxes, although he and Tchakarova seize the grandeur. Lastly, this group finishes with Im Walde, an vigorous romp by out of doors Schubert, that turns into extra intent and severe because the drama develops.
When it got here to composition, Amy Seashore was primarily an autodidact, her predominant coaching being in piano. Which means her music is very influenced by the German romantic custom with out a lot of a nod to later, extra superior composers resembling Liszt or Wagner. Married to a person significantly older than herself, her marital standing prevented her from giving public performances and composition turned key. Her husband appears to have been a giant affect, and after his loss of life (and that of her controlling mom), Seashore not often wrote large-scale orchestral varieties.
These 4 songs all date from this early interval earlier than her husband died. All 4 set German texts. Ich sagte nicht from her Opus 51 (1903) combines tenderness with a strongly romantic but chromaticism with the 2 performers giving the track their full expressive consideration. Wir Drei (additionally from Opus 51) is maybe extra intense, but no much less rigorously crafted with some attention-grabbing harmonic diversions and the steadily suggestion of a waltz. Nachts from her Opus 35 (1896) is quiet and intimate, the 2 performers creating a young, hushed ambiance. Additionally from Opus 35, Nahe des Geliebten is a setting of Goethe (the one well-known poet within the group) which is splendidly lyrically participating, but remarkably expansive with Seashore making the strophic type right into a kind of gradual construct.
While recognized for different works together with his piano concerto, Austrian composer Joseph Marx wrote round 150 songs, together with a outstanding quantity from his early years when composing. Waldseligkeit, setting Richard Dehmel introduces to Marx’s remarkably wealthy and refulgent type. Completely singable, the track is notable for the richly textured piano half and the sense of Expressionist drama. Gedenkst du noch der Nacht is extra intimate with a conversational strategy to the vocal line, mixed nonetheless with refulgent piano. Vale carissima is extra strophic, the slightly standard vocal line surrounded by extra luxuriant piano which pushes the soundworld nearer to a few of Marx’s extra adventurous contemporaries. Warte noch ein kleines Weilchen is brief, but lyrically participating and slightly conventional, nearly backward wanting. Morgengruss is barely two verses lengthy but remarkably expansive and our two performers give the track their utmost focus, making each be aware depend. Regen does certainly evoke rain within the piano, but Marx permits the concord to wander greater than we would anticipate and the track offers the sense of an inside monologue with some slightly highly effective moments. The textual content by Richard von Schaukal is a translation of Verlaine. To complete, one other translation this time of Sao Han (1788-1857), Ein junger Dichter denkt an die Geliebte, a slightly sober, severe track but with some actually magical piano textures.
The CD booklet is considerably irritating for English audio system, there are wonderful translations of the booklet article and biographies, nice photos, however the track texts are solely in German. The illustrations within the booklet characteristic artwork by Regula Humm who occurs to be the baritone’s grandmother!
I’m not certain that this recital actually wants its theme, and generally Daniel Ernst’s article appears to veer into particular pleading. However as a recital, transferring from the recognized to the unknown, this can be a extremely creditable and fascinating disc. The 2 performers give weight to all of the composers on the disc, and their perception in Seashore and Marx’s very totally different late romantic worlds actually brings the songs to life, and in our polystylistic age we not fear that neither composer was significantly superior!
Libertas
Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827) – Flohlied
Ludwig van Beethoven – Sehnsucht
Ludwig van Beethoven – Der Liebende
Ludwig van Beethoven – An die Hoffnung
Franz Schubert (1797-1828) – Der entsühnte Orest
Franz Schubert – An mein Herz
Franz Schubert – Sehnsucht
Franz Schubert – Gruppe aus dem Tartarus
Franz Schubert – Im Walde
Amy Seashore (1867-1944) – Ich sagte nicht
Amy Seashore – Wir Drei
Amy Seashore – Nachts
Amy Seashore – Nahe des Geliebten
Joseph Marx (1882-1964) – Waldseligkeit
Joseph Marx – Gedenkst du noch der Nacht
Joseph Marx – Vale carissima
Joseph Marx – Warte noch ein kleines Weilchen
Joseph Marx – Morgengruss
Joseph Marx – Regen
Joseph Marx – Ein junger Dichter denkt an die Geliebte
Äneas Humm (baritone)
Doriana Tchakarova (piano)
Recorded 28-31 October 2024, Immanuelllskirche Wuppertal
RONDEAU PRODUCTION ROP6275 1CD [69:00]
The weblog is free, however I would be delighted if you happen to had been to point out your appreciation by shopping for me a espresso.
Elsewhere on this weblog
- Exceptional depth: highly effective new Nineteen Eighties-set Peter Grimes from Melly Nonetheless at Welsh Nationwide Opera with Nicky Spence – opera assessment
- Telling a musical story: violinist James Ehnes on the challenges of recording of Bach’s violin concertos with Canada’s NAC Orchestra – interview
- Highly effective stuff: Ukrainian composer Boris Lyatoshynsky’s dramatic war-inspired symphony alongside Prokofiev’s Semyon Kotko – live performance assessment
- Creativeness & sense of drama: John Weldon’s 1701 prize-winning The Judgement of Paris in its first recording from Academy of Historic Music & Cambridge Handel Opera Co – document assessment
- Up shut and private: David Butt Philip & Associates Gala at St Paul’s Opera, Clapham – opera assessment
- Pure enjoyment: Peter Moore & Tredegar Band give the primary recording of Simon Dobson’s concerto for Moore – document assessment
- Bespoke Songs: soprano Fotina Naumenko on commissioning 4 composers for works for soprano and various ensembles – interview
- Richard Strauss on the Deutsche Oper Berlin:
- Traces of trauma: Britten Sinfonia premiere Michael Zev Gordon’s A Type of Haunting marking eightieth anniversary of the top of WWII – live performance assessment
- Dwelling